Why does slate fail at the nail rather than the stone?
Slate is durable stone, and the fixing is usually the weak link. Plain steel and galvanized nails corrode, and corroded nails let slates slip or crack. Non-ferrous nails are the standard the Park Service sets for historic slate.
As a nail corrodes it loses its grip, the slate drops, and the slate below takes the extra weight. A slipped slate also exposes the nail heads of the course beneath it, and those heads let water in at the top of the next slate down.
Driving the nail is the other half. A nail driven too deep cracks the slate it holds, and one driven too shallow does not hold the stone at all. An overdriven nail is replaced rather than left to crack the stone over time.
Can a slate roof be repaired without replacing the whole roof?
Usually yes. Cracked, slipped and rusted slates can be replaced or re-fixed section by section, provided the decking and flashings are sound. Full replacement is for a roof where most of the slopes have failed.
The decking under the slates decides how far a repair can go. If the boards are sound, the work stays with the slates and fixings. If the decking is soft or rotted nails have weakened the boards, the repair grows, and the scope is written only after the decking has been looked at.
Salvage matters. Sound slates can be reused, and a technician sorts them as the work goes, so that what is kept is kept on purpose. A new slate's color and thickness are shown on the roof before it goes in.
Does a slate repair need a permit?
It depends on the scope and the address. In Stamford, ordinary repairs are generally treated as repairs, while larger roofing work runs through the Building Department's own track. Confirm the position for the address before work starts.
Stamford's Building Department lists a roofing application track, and its frequently asked questions say a permit is not required for ordinary repairs to structures. The FAQ is dated, so the homeowner should confirm the current position directly.
Slate on a historic house can carry its own review. The authority to ask is the one for the address, and this site does not say whether any particular property is in a historic district.
What moves the cost of slate repair?
Cost follows how many slates and fixings are involved, how easily they can be reached and what the decking and flashings need. It is explained and approved before any work starts, and this site prints no figure for it.
Pitch and access matter. A steep slate roof on a large house needs more care in walking and more time to lift and re-fix each slate. A section with several planes and valleys needs careful work at every joint, and slate that must be matched or salvaged adds time.
Under the slate is where cost can change. Corroded nails, soft decking and failed flashing only show once the stone is lifted, and each option is explained before any work is approved.